Episode 1607 – The Holdovers: a rare gem

December 3, 2025  

Season 16

This is storytelling at its finest. We could study it to learn about almost any aspect of writing, but this week, Melanie and I are highlighting the complexity and nuance of the main character. He’s a passive character, which makes for an especially interesting study of both the hero’s monologue and the shadow. If you’ve not seen THE HOLDOVERS yet, watch it as a gift to yourself this holiday season. You won’t be disappointed. We’ll be back in January with a new episode. Until then, we’ll be sharing some of our favourite episodes from the vault! Happy Holidays, everyone! And Happy New Year! – V.

(The following summary was generated by A.I.)

In the latest episode of our podcast, we delve into the intricacies of storytelling, focusing on the hero’s monologue as demonstrated in the film ‘The Holdovers.’ This film, directed by Alexander Payne, provides a rich case study for writers looking to enhance their narrative skills. Melanie Hill and Valerie Francis guide listeners through the essential storytelling principles that every writer should understand. They emphasize the importance of analyzing how other writers apply these principles in their work, which is a crucial step in developing one’s own storytelling abilities. The episode begins with Valerie discussing the significance of the hero’s monologue, particularly in character-driven stories. She explains that this narrative device reveals the protagonist’s desires and motivations, allowing the audience to connect with the character on a deeper level. In ‘The Holdovers,’ we observe two distinct protagonists: Paul Hunnam, a teacher, and Angus Tully, a student. Their intersecting storylines offer a unique perspective on the classic arc plot and mini-plot forms of storytelling. Listeners are treated to an analysis of Angus’s straightforward hero’s monologue, where he grapples with his father’s mental health and his own feelings of abandonment. This moment is pivotal, as it encapsulates his burning desire to reconnect with his father, driving his actions throughout the film. In contrast, Paul’s monologue is more complex, reflecting his passive nature and the repercussions of his past mistakes. Valerie expertly dissects how Paul’s character is shaped by his experiences, illustrating the importance of understanding a character’s background to enrich their development. Throughout the episode, Melanie and Valerie underscore that storytelling is not a rigid formula but rather an art form that allows for creativity and flexibility. They encourage writers to explore the nuances of their characters and the dynamics of their relationships, as these elements are vital to crafting compelling narratives. As the discussion progresses, the hosts highlight the significance of having both active and passive characters in a story. They point out that without a balance between these dynamics, a narrative may lack depth and engagement. This insight is particularly valuable for writers looking to create multi-dimensional characters who resonate with readers. In conclusion, this episode serves as a treasure trove of information for writers at any stage of their journey. By dissecting ‘The Holdovers,’ Melanie and Valerie provide listeners with practical tips and a deeper understanding of storytelling principles. Whether you’re working on a character-driven story or exploring different narrative forms, this episode is an invaluable resource that will inspire you to refine your craft and create stories that captivate your audience. Tune in to unlock the secrets of effective storytelling!